Search: Web        
powered by
Serial Shooter Trial ~

Archive for the 'Jurors' Category

Jurors appear to be losing interest

December 18th, 2008, 3:12 pm by Nick R. Martin

After more than two months of testimony, many of the jurors seem to be going through some sort of vacation-itis. Most have stopped taking notes. Some are yawning from time to time. Some aren’t even looking at the forensic scientists on the witness stand today. They all appear ready for a long break.

They’re going to get it, too. Today is the last day of the trial for the year. The trial will be on vacation from tomorrow through the New Year. However, today brings some of the most important forensic evidence of the case to date. A former Mesa police DNA analyst named Virginia Smart just took the stand and is expected to tell the jury that she found Dale Hausner’s DNA on a pair of latex gloves that also had gunshot residue on them. This would explain why his fingerprints were not found on the recently-fired shotguns seized in a search of his apartment and car following his arrest in August 2006.

Tuesday wrap: Secret police recordings heard in courtroom

December 10th, 2008, 12:16 am by Nick R. Martin

Out of the soft fuzz and hiss of background noise came a voice, rough and deep.

“It now brings the total to six,” the man said, talking about news reports of a spate of recent killings throughout the Valley.

“It’s higher than that!” said another, his voice higher-pitched and louder. “What about the guy I (expletive) shot at twice at 27th Avenue in the yard?”

Jurors on Tuesday in a downtown Phoenix courtroom heard the garbled recordings of two men boasting and cheering about the Serial Shooter killing spree, which in reality had left eight people dead by that point.

Dale Hausner, the man heard with the higher-pitched voice, was only a few feet away in the courtroom, sitting stone-faced and listening as prosecutors and police said it helped prove that he and the other man, Samuel Dieteman, were responsible for the killings.

In all, prosecutors played about a dozen snippets from more than four hours of secret police recordings made on Aug. 3, 2006, just prior to midnight when they arrested the pair at their Mesa apartment.

The audio recordings were some of the most-anticipated and explicit evidence to be presented by Maricopa County prosecutors as part Hausner’s lengthy murder trial.Dieteman, believed to be the accomplice, has pleaded guilty to two murders and agreed to testify against his former roommate in the coming weeks.

The recordings, played publicly for the first time, revealed that Hausner and Dieteman talked almost obsessively about media coverage of the Serial Shooter killing spree, which had been going on since May 2005.

In one snippet played for jurors, they talked about a news report that mentioned a “new” detail that the Serial Shooter often roamed and circled around certain areas of the Valley looking for victims.

“You think?” Hausner shouted on the recording. “You dumb (expletive.) It took you a year-and-a-half to come up with that? Wow.”

In another snippet, the men talked about their individual techniques.

“I try to wait to the last second when somebody’s getting near me,” Dieteman said. “I don’t even think I get it level. I just get it to where it’s pointed at somebody.”

Hausner was heard mumbling something inaudible in the recording, then mimicking a gunshot. “And bam!”

Read full story…

Submitted photo. Dale Hausner shakes hands with boxer Mike Tyson in this undated photo. Hausner was heard on secret audio recordings Tuesday saying he hoped Tyson would volunteer his time searching for a suspect in the Serial Shooter killings that plagued the Valley in 2005 and 2006.

Secret recordings were hotly contested

December 9th, 2008, 1:45 pm by Nick R. Martin

The secret recording of Dale Hausner and Sam Dieteman will likely be hard for the jury to ignore, but it almost didn’t make it into the trial at all. More than a year ago, Hausner’s defense team started trying to get the recordings thrown out, saying they were illegal because they were obtained without a search warrant.

At issue was the somewhat unconventional way that authorities went about getting approval to plant bugs in the car, apartment and telephones of the Serial Shooter suspects. Instead of going to a judge and getting a warrant, authorities went to Maricopa County’s chief prosecutor, Andrew Thomas, for what’s known as an “emergency” wiretap. Under state law, an elected prosecutor can OK the secret wiretap under dire circumstances. Once it’s approved, a judge must sign off on the already-planted bugs within two days.

Hausner’s defense team basically said the procedure was unconstitutional. The issue even became political as one of Thomas’ challengers prior to his re-election in November said the prosecutor put the entire case in jeopardy by approving this unusual procedure.

The defense ended up forcing a series of hearings on the recordings, which peaked in April with dramatic testimony from Thomas himself in which he said he approved the emergency wiretaps to “stop the killing.”

Eventually, in June, Steinle approved the wiretaps, giving jurors the change to hear the recordings.

Today, those wiretaps will be heard in public for the first time as prosecutors begin to present hours of the recording, beginning any minute now.

Photo by pool photographer. Dale Hausner, left, listens to testimony with one of his attorneys, Timothy Agan, in October.

Juror gets sick; trial ends for the day

November 20th, 2008, 1:31 pm by Nick R. Martin

Even the most-scripted trials run into a wall sometimes. Judge Roland Steinle announced before the lunch break that one of the jurors has come down sick. That means the testimony about Robin Blasnek’s murder, as well as the end of the first segment of the prosecution’s case, will be delayed until after Thanksgiving.

The trial is off all next week for the holiday, but check back here tomorrow for a small story wrapping up this week’s developments. Then, live blogging from the trial will begin again on Dec. 1.

Deja vu: Juror caught snoozing again

November 18th, 2008, 3:31 pm by Nick R. Martin

It has been almost a month since a young juror in the front row was caught napping and told to stay awake. He denied he was sleeping, but still promised to load himself up with “a couple Red Bulls” to remain alert during testimony. Well, according to defense attorney Ken Everett, it hasn’t been enough.

This afternoon, while the jury was out of the room on a short break, Everett complained to Judge Roland Steinle that the young man was again seen with his eyes closed and appeared to be snoozing during testimony. Steinle said he would keep an eye on it for the rest of the day. When the man came back into the room after the break, he was carrying a bottle of Mountain Dew.

Photo used under free distribution licensing from Wikimedia Commons.

Survival and stoicism the keys for ‘Shooter’ victim

November 13th, 2008, 11:24 am by Nick R. Martin

He is the only witness to be in court watching the proceedings every day since the trial began. Today, Paul Patrick got his chance to testify.

Patrick was shot on the night of June 8, 2006 while walking near an auto repair shop at 78th Avenue and Indian School Road in Phoeix. “I heard a loud bang and felt a great deal of pain,” Patrick testified this morning. “I spun around and hit the ground hard — on my belly.”

On its own, Patrick’s testimony does not stand out among the dozens of crimes authorities have tied to Serial Shooter suspect Dale Hausner, who is on trial for the crime spree. Like many of the other victims, he was alone. It was nighttime. He was walking on the side of the street on his way to nowhere in particular.

But the 48-year-old Patrick could prove to be a compelling figure for the jury. Day after day, he comes into the courtroom with the help of a motorized wheelchair. He can walk, but he hobbles when he does so. It’s painful to stand or walk, he testified. He also comes to the sixth-floor courtroom every day with his mother at his side. Together, they sit stoically in the first row, just behind the prosecutors. They listen to the testimony of others, as they have done with nearly 80 witnesses in the trial so far, and they sometimes nod because they can relate.

“I was in intensive care for 19 straight days,” Patrick said on the stand. “Then I was transfered for St. Luke’s (Hospital) for another three weeks or a month. I can’t remember.” He had multiple surgeries in the months following his shooting, including the removal of most of his colon.

Before today, none of the jurors knew why Patrick was in the courtroom every day. After today, he will be a constant reminder of the pain caused by the 14-month string of shootings.

Map shows the location where Paul Patrick was shot the night of June 8, 2006. Click here for a larger, interactive map.

Note: This post originally said Patrick was 36 years old. He is, in fact, 48.

Trial highlights to hold you over till Monday

November 6th, 2008, 4:21 pm by Nick R. Martin


The trial is on hold until Monday, so why not catch up with what you might’ve missed?

Highlights so far:
Man identifies Hausner as attacker
‘A young woman crawling in the street’
The bloodiest night of the killing spree
Surveillance camera captured car near 3 shootings
Juror: I may look like I’m falling asleep, but…
Witness says Hausner confessed to shooting
Hausner disputes Tribune story

Photo by Paul O’Neill, Tribune. Phoenix teen Kibili Tambadu shows where he ran after being shot in May 2006. Prosecutors say Dale Hausner, a Mesa man suspected of being the Serial Shooter, was behind the shooting.

Courthouse may be evacuated

October 29th, 2008, 11:23 am by Nick R. Martin

Judge Steinle warned the courtroom that the building may have to be evacuated this morning because of a fire drill. Apparently a rumor is circulating in the halls that an alarm will go off any minute now. If that’s the case, jurors will be the first to leave the courtroom, then Hausner will be escorted out a side door. Elevators are off limits and the court staff will have to figure out how to maintain order as the three high-rise buildings that make up the courthouse are emptied.

Meanwhile, Phoenix police detective Cliff Jewell continues his testimony about the Toyota Camry spotted near the scenes of three shootings the night of Dec. 29, 2005. The testimony is important because Hausner drove a car seemingly identical to the one captured on camera that night. This is at least the third day of testimony involving a surveillance camera and the car.

Photo from Google Street View. Maricopa County Superior Court’s Central Building.

Juror’s boss threatens to cut off health care

October 29th, 2008, 10:47 am by Nick R. Martin

A juror just told Judge Roland Steinle that her boss has threatened to cut off her health insurance if she remains on the trial past the end of the month. A blond woman in the back row, Juror No. 5 said that her employer, Lehigh Hanson Aggregates, wants the court to pay for her health care if she is to stay.

The problem, Steinle said, is that the court doesn’t have the cash to pay for anyone’s health care. He also said he consulted with attorneys and believes the company’s move is illegal. “Under the statute, you can’t be penalized for being on the jury,” Steinle said. He plans to send a letter to the company, then refer the woman to the Arizona Attorney General’s Office.

However, Steinle said, if the company plays hardball, the woman may have to be excused from the jury. “Particularly in these economic times,” Steinle said, he doesn’t want someone to go without health insurance.

Programming note: Off until Monday

October 24th, 2008, 2:15 pm by Nick R. Martin

The trial of Serial Shooter suspect Dale Hausner is off today, but it will return on Monday, Oct. 27. Live blogging will also resume that morning. In the meantime, catch up with the trial.

Last week’s highlights:
Bloody night of shootings reached across Valley
Surveillance camera capture car near 3 shootings
Juror denies napping in court
Everett’s antics earn him an earful from judge
Witness says Hausner confessed to shooting
Hausner disputes Tribune story

ADVERTISEMENT