Search: Web        
powered by
Serial Shooter Trial ~

Archive for the 'Witness' Tag

Bearing witness, his ‘beautiful duty’

November 16th, 2008, 1:11 pm by Nick R. Martin

He sits every day in the front row of the gallery, quietly watching a parade of horrors, sometimes nodding, mostly staring straight ahead.

One after another, witnesses take the stand in the downtown Phoenix courtroom, each talking about some ghastly injury or murder. All the while, Paul Patrick sits nearly motionless and listens.

The physical pain and psychological damage caused by the Serial Shooters, who authorities say cruised the Valley in 2005 and 2006 looking for easy targets, are as real to Patrick as they are to anyone. He was shot like many of the others. Blasted by a shotgun while walking alone at night.

He still carries inside his body 100 pellets that doctors were never able to remove. He still wakes up with nightmares and throbbing pain.

Whatever almost anyone says on the stand about the time he or she was shot or the day a loved one died, Patrick can relate to it.

And that’s why he’s quietly watching the trial of Serial Shooter suspect Dale Hausner.

Patrick, 48, sees himself as “the face of the victims.”

He is one of at least 17 people who authorities say survived the cruelty of Hausner, a Mesa man accused in a 14-month string of shootings, which included eight killings.

The court has allowed victims to sit in on every part of the trial so far. It is a courtesy not extended to other witnesses like police officers or medical examiners.

But since opening arguments took place on Oct. 6, Patrick has been the only survivor in court every day.

In an interview on Friday, a day after he testified in the case, Patrick said he sees himself as sort of an unofficial representative of the many lives taken or changed by the shooting spree.

“It’s my beautiful duty,” Patrick said. “They’re not just going to be insignificant names. There’s going to be a face to this. It’s going to be human.”

Read full story…

Photo by Julio Jimenez, Tribune. Paul Patrick, 48, of Phoenix testified in the Serial Shooter trial Thursday.  He shows the wounds he suffered when he was shot at close range with a shotgun in June of 2006. Programming note: Trial coverage will return Monday.

Wednesday wrap: 2 place Hausner at attack scenes

November 5th, 2008, 8:51 pm by Nick R. Martin

Two witnesses. Both with different stories. Both with the same conclusion: It was Dale Hausner.

A month into a marathon eight-count murder trial, two people on Wednesday placed Hausner, the Serial Shooter suspect, at the scenes of separate attacks in May 2006.

It was the clearest link yet between the 35-year-old Mesa man and the 14-month string of murders and assaults that stretched across the Valley two years ago.

Hausner looked fidgety and nervous in court as the witnesses told their stories, but that didn’t keep his defense attorneys from aggressively trying to pick apart the testimony.

The first person to identify Hausner in court was Timothy Davenport, who was stabbed nearly to death by two strangers on May 17, 2006, as he was walking to a friend’s house in west Phoenix.

Davenport, 36, said he was crossing through a church parking lot just after midnight near 73rd Avenue and Camelback Road when a car pulled into the lot and the driver stopped to ask him a question.

“Are you OK?” the driver asked, according to Davenport.

Before he could answer, another man came from behind and stabbed him in the back, side and face. Davenport pointed to the scars he has from the attack.

Asked whether either of his attackers was in court on Wednesday, Davenport pointed to Hausner and identified him as the driver.

“He was the one that distracted me while the other guy stabbed me,” Davenport said. “One hundred percent.”

Read full story…

Programming note: The trial is taking a long weekend, and so is this blog. Live courtroom updates will resume Monday.

Two Dale Hausners, one with a mustache

November 5th, 2008, 3:49 pm by Nick R. Martin

Timothy Davenport said the only attacker he could identify from the night of his stabbing had a mustache and red hair. And the defense team has a problem with that. Dale Hausner, the man sitting in court today accused of the crime, is clean shaven and sporting arguably dirty blond hair. The jurors might have to squint hard to picture Hausner with either of the other characteristics.

It’s not so hard to imagine it, though, if you see the photos from the time of Hausner’s arrest. Take a look at his booking photo to the far right. It’s strikingly different than the image of Hausner in court last month. The booking photo distorts Hausner’s skin tone and hair color a little bit, but it shows him with a mustache and beard. Other photos from the time of his arrest show that Hausner’s hair was lighter and reddish in August 2006 when police arrested him and his confessed co-conspirator Samuel Dieteman.

Still, Hausner’s defense team attacked these differences this afternoon, quizzing Davenport about his attackers and how he identified Hausner as one of them. Davenport said he was able to see Hausner’s face for 6 seconds the night he was stabbed. He said Hausner pulled up in front of him one night while he was walking in a parking lot and asked if he was OK. That’s when “a dark figure,” who authorities have said was Jeff Hausner, Dale’s brother, came up behind Davenport and stabbed him multiple times.

Davenport admitted, however, that it was dark that night and he didn’t get a very good look at either man. “That night, the only light was coming from the streetlights themselves,” he testified. Hausner’s attorneys seized on this, trying to show that his identification of Hausner may not be reliable.

Tuesday wrap: Witness says he was ignored

October 15th, 2008, 8:53 am by Nick R. Martin

A man whose dog was one of the earliest victims of the Serial Shooter killings testified on Tuesday that police ignored many of his tips and leads in the case.

Carl Zolnarchik said he was even told at one point to stop e-mailing investigators with the Phoenix and Tolleson police departments because they thought his constant prodding was a nuisance.

“They were ignoring your e-mails, weren’t they, Carl?” asked Ken Everett, the defense attorney for Serial Shooter suspect Dale Hausner.

“I believe so,” Zolnarchik replied.

The Tolleson man’s statements came during the second full day of testimony in the trial of Hausner, a Mesa man accused of killing eight people and numerous animals from May 2005 to August 2006.

When Zolnarchik’s dog, Whiskey, was killed on July 19, 2005, investigators had not yet connected the long chain of seemingly random West Valley shootings.

It’s not clear whether Zolnarchik’s leads could have helped investigators connect the dots or solve the crimes sooner or whether they were relevant to the case at all.

By that time, according to police and prosecutors, Hausner had already killed three people and would kill five others before he was through.

Read full story…

Photo by pool photographer. Prosecutor Laura Reckart questions a witness Tuesday in the trial of Dale Hausner, the Mesa man suspected of being one of two Serial Shooters.

Witness says police ignored his tips

October 14th, 2008, 2:18 pm by Nick R. Martin

After Carl Zolnarchik’s dog, Whiskey, was shot and killed during the summer of 2005, he flooded the Phoenix and Tolleson police departments with possible leads. Someone was recently throwing cans of Bud Light at his dogs at night, he told them, and it stopped after the shooting. He later asked police to dust some of the saved cans for fingerprints. They refused. He told them about strange Chevy and Dodge pickup trucks he saw in the area driven by a mysterious man with a dark mustache and baseball cap. They never followed up.

Eventually, Zolnarchik said on the stand this afternoon, the Phoenix Police Department asked him to stop sending e-mails with leads.

“They were ignoring your e-mails, weren’t they, Carl?” asked defense attorney Ken Everett.

“I believe so,” Zolnarchik said.

It’s not clear whether any of the information Zolnarchik tried to pass on to police would have been useful in catching the Serial Shooter suspects. But Everett seems to have seized on the testimony as a sign that police were too lazy or inept to follow through on the July 19, 2005 shooting.

Photo by pool photographer. Hausner’s attorney, Ken Everett, questions witnesses Tuesday in court.

ADVERTISEMENT